1answer
81views
Should I repair or replace my roof?
Asked May 12, 2026 by a contractor in Roofing (Handyman Mod)
A few leaks and some missing shingles. How do I know whether to patch it or replace the whole thing?
AllAdd Attic spaceAir ConditioningAppliance - RepairAppliance Installation and RepairArchitectAsbestos Siding - RepairAtticsBasementsBathroom RemodelingBlown-In InsulationBrick and Stone - FlooringCabinetsCarpentryCleaningCloset - BuildConcreteCountertopsCustom Home BuildingCustomer Home RemodelingDecksDesignerDoorsDrivewaysDrywall and PlasteringElectricalExterior Trim - InstallFans and VentilationFencingFinancingFinish Carpentry, Trim and MoldingFireplaceFloor CoveringsFlooringFloorsFoundationsFraming SystemsGarages and OutbuildingsGeneral ContractorsGlass and ScreensGuttersHandymanHandyman for Multiple Small ProjectsHeating and VentilationHome AdditionsInspection - RoofingInspection and AppraisalInsulation and Weather StrippingKitchen RemodelingLandscapingMasonryOdd-JobsOtherOther HVAC TypesPaint PreparationPaint Removal and CleaningPainting and WallcoveringPavingPest ControlPlumbingPoolsRailingsRemodeling and Room AdditionsRetaining WallsRoofingSiding/ResidingTile, Stone, Grout - CleanTile: Ceramic and Porcelain - InstallWallsWaterproofingWindows
Join this discussion
Contractors reply here; homeowners use HomeManager.
1 reply
Sort:
- H
Repair if the roof is under ~15 years old and the damage is localized (a few missing shingles, one leak). Replace if it's near end of life, has widespread granule loss, sagging, or repeated leaks — patching an old roof throws good money after bad. A reputable roofer will show you photos and give you both options with costs.
Loading…